Skip to content
WordPress site playing up? Vincony fixes it — today, from $5.Get it fixed →
The Great Britain Guide logoThe Great Britain Guide

Memorials & monuments · Central Scotland

Melville Monument

Also known as: Carragh Melville

In or near Comrie.

Free admission🐾 Dog-friendly

Melville Monument is a memorial in the United Kingdom.

Hole in the wall, Melville Monument - geograph.org.uk - 7028060

Richard Webb — CC BY-SA 2.0 via Wikimedia Commons licence

Plan your visit

Typical visit
15 min–45 min
  • Free entry
  • Dog-friendly

About

Melville Monument is a public memorial or monument in the United Kingdom. Also known as: Carragh Melville. Coordinates: 56.3873°, -3.9995°.

Photo gallery

Heritage listing

The Melville Monument is a large column in St Andrew Square, Edinburgh constructed between 1821 and 1827 as a memorial to Scottish statesman Henry Dundas, 1st Viscount Melville. Dundas, one of the most prominent Scotsmen of his day, was a dominant figure in British politics during much of the late 18th century. Plans to construct a memorial to him began soon after his death in 1811 and were largely driven by Royal Navy officers, especially Sir William Johnstone Hope. After a successful campaign for subscriptions, construction of the monument began in 1821 but time and costs soon spiralled out of control. The project was not completed until 1827 and not paid off until 1837.

From Historic Environment Scotland under OGL v3.

From the Wikipedia article

The Melville Monument is a large column in St Andrew Square, Edinburgh constructed between 1821 and 1827 as a memorial to Scottish statesman Henry Dundas, 1st Viscount Melville. Dundas, one of the most prominent Scotsmen of his day, was a dominant figure in British politics during much of the late 18th century. Plans to construct a memorial to him began soon after his death in 1811 and were largely driven by Royal Navy officers, especially Sir William Johnstone Hope. After a successful campaign for subscriptions, construction of the monument began in 1821 but time and costs soon spiralled out of control. The project was not completed until 1827 and not paid off until 1837. In the 21st century, the monument became the subject of increasing controversy as a result of claims that Dundas had delayed the abolition of the slave trade in the British Empire. In the wake of protests following the murder of George Floyd in 2020, the City of Edinburgh Council affixed a plaque to the monument blaming Dundas for "deferring the abolition of the Atlantic slave trade" as well as "imposing colonial rule on indigenous peoples", in accordance with the recommendations of the Edinburgh Slavery and Colonialism Legacy Review. Installation of the plaque was completed in October 2021. In March 2023, the council's planning committee voted to remove the contentious plaque, but the council later stated that it did not intend to do so. Designed by William Burn, the column is modelled after Trajan's Column in Rome. Robert Stevenson provided additional engineering advice during construction. The column is topped by a 4.2 m (14 ft) tall statue of Dundas designed by Francis Leggatt Chantrey and carved by Robert Forrest. The total height of the monument is about 45 m (150 ft). It is one of Edinburgh's most prominent landmarks.

Excerpt from Wikipedia under CC BY-SA 4.0. See the source article linked in Sources below.

Background

Architecture

in the construction of the Bell Rock Lighthouse; at Stevenson's recommendation, J. & J. Rutherford used a similar crane to construct the Melville Monument.]] Soon after the contract was signed, Patrick Walker attempted to sue the committee for "breach of engagement" and claim damages of £10,000. In the end, the committee settled for £408, effectively tipping the project into debt. Debt and delay grew, especially after an assessment by Robert Stevenson recommend strengthening the foundations and constructing the shaft from solid blocks rather than rubble infill as Burn had proposed. Stevenson's assessment was offered free of charge and had been spurred by the square's residents, many of whom…

Sourced from Wikipedia under CC BY-SA 4.0.

Coordinates
56.3873, -3.9995
Postcode
PH6 2LX
Parliamentary constituency
Perth and Kinross-shire
Opening
| restore = 2008

Sources

Other places nearby

Nearby

Woodland below Lord Melville's monument - geograph.org.uk - 2297016📷 5

Mountains & hills · Central Scotland

Dun More

Dun More — a hill or mountain in scotland central.

🐕
Looking north across Dun More - geograph.org.uk - 8144961📷 5

Mountains & hills · Central Scotland

Dun More

Dun More — mountain in scotland central. Elevation: 256 m.

🐕
Deil's Cauldron, Glen Lednock - geograph.org.uk - 7028051📷 3

Viewpoints · Central Scotland

Deil's Cauldron

Deil's Cauldron is a viewpoint in the United Kingdom.

Free🐕
Sign to the Monument - with 5 point plan^ - geograph.org.uk - 2432806📷 5

Waterfalls · Central Scotland

Deil's Cauldron

Deil's Cauldron — waterfall in scotland central.

The River Lednock in Laggan Wood - geograph.org.uk - 2433141📷 5

Waterfalls · Central Scotland

Wee Cauldron

Wee Cauldron — waterfall in scotland central.

Little Cauldron, Glen Lednock - geograph.org.uk - 7028022📷 3

Viewpoints · Central Scotland

Wee Cauldron

Wee Cauldron is a viewpoint in the United Kingdom.

Free🐕

Where to eat & stay near Melville Monument

Places to stay

Stone House, The Ross, Comrie - geograph.org.uk - 2422312📷 5

Caravan parks · Central Scotland

Twenty Shilling Wood Caravan Park

Twenty Shilling Wood Caravan Park — a caravan park in scotland central.

Freetwentyshillingwoodholidaypark.co.uk
A85 near Comrie - geograph.org.uk - 7793319📷 5

Caravan parks · Central Scotland

West Lodge Caravan Park

West Lodge Caravan Park — a caravan park in scotland central.

Faint path into the woods - geograph.org.uk - 6897006📷 5

Caravan parks · Central Scotland

Campervan Site

Campervan Site — a caravan park in scotland central.

Faint path into the woods - geograph.org.uk - 6897006📷 5

Hostels · Central Scotland

Comrie Croft Steading

Comrie Croft Steading — a hostel in scotland central.

comriecroft.com
Faint path into the woods - geograph.org.uk - 6897006📷 5

Hostels · Central Scotland

Comrie Croft Farmhouse

Comrie Croft Farmhouse — a hostel in scotland central.

Freecomriecroft.com
Faint path into the woods - geograph.org.uk - 6897006📷 5

Campsites · Central Scotland

Slow Worm

Slow Worm — a campsite in scotland central.

More memorials in this region

Cairn on Pyatshaw Ridge - geograph.org.uk - 375408📷 3

Memorials & monuments · Central Scotland

Mutiny Stones

Mutiny Stones in England North East, United Kingdom.

Free🐕
Augusta, Princess Dowager of Wales Monument📷 3

Memorials & monuments · Central Scotland

Augusta, Princess Dowager of Wales Monument

Augusta, Princess Dowager of Wales Monument is a memorial in the United Kingdom.

Free🐕mountstuart.com
The Pencil, Largs - geograph.org.uk - 3604686📷 3

Memorials & monuments · Central Scotland

Battle of Largs Monument

Battle of Largs Monument — Monument, dating to 1912.

Free🐕
Railway Bridge, Arbroath - geograph.org.uk - 744261📷 3

Memorials & monuments · Central Scotland

Declaration of Arbroath Monument

Declaration of Arbroath Monument is a memorial in the United Kingdom.

Free🐕

Frequently asked questions

Where is Melville Monument?
Melville Monument is in central Scotland, United Kingdom (postcode PH6 2LX).
What is Melville Monument?
Melville Monument is a memorial in the United Kingdom.
How do I get to Melville Monument?
Drivers can use postcode PH6 2LX.
Is Melville Monument a listed building?
Melville Monument is officially recognised as category B listed building listed.
Is Melville Monument free to visit?
Yes, Melville Monument is free to enter.
How do I get to Melville Monument?
Drivers can navigate to postcode PH6 2LX. It sits within the Perth and Kinross-shire parliamentary constituency.